"This is going to be a critical part of the game," Bochy said.
With Gerardo Parra at bat and two outs, Giants right-hander Matt Cain attempted to pick A.J. Pollock off first base. Moments after umpire Chris Guccione called Pollock safe, Bochy left the dugout to announce his challenge. The umpiring crew motioned for Pollock to remain at first base a little more than a minute later.
The Giants felt the sequence's aftereffects. After the call was upheld, Parra doubled to right, advancing Pollock to third base. With Aaron Hill batting, Cain threw an outside pitch that catcher Buster Posey couldn't hold, resulting in a passed ball. Posey chased the ball and threw it to Cain, who covered home plate. Cain reached across the plate to tag the sliding Pollock, who was ruled safe in a close play.
"That was just a weird play," Pollock said. "Buster got crossed up by a heater or a cutter or something. It was just really weird seeing that, and I thought it was going to kick all the way to the backstop. It was kind of one of those where he flipped his glove a little bit and deadened the ball a little more than I expected. Everyone is saying I was out. I kind of did a kick stop and hop over the glove there, and I kept looking at the replay. I didn't feel a tag and I kept looking. It was a pretty gutsy call by the umpire, but I think he got it right."
Bochy again left the dugout to argue, but he couldn't challenge the call because he already had exhausted that privilege.
"That's what you call a hang with 'em," Bochy said. "You can't do anything at that point because you've already lost your challenge. This is how the system works and you understand that. Would I have changed anything? No. You don't know whether you're going to get another call when you wish you could challenge."
Joe Garagiola Jr., Major League Baseball's vice president of baseball operations, happened to be in attendance and commented on what transpired.
"Yeah, that's what can happen," he said. "[Bochy] used his challenge, and because he was wrong, that's it, he has no more challenges. And until the seventh inning, the umpires have no ability on their own to even go look at a replay."
Chris Haft is a reporter for MLB.com. Read his blog, Haft-Baked Ideas, and follow him on Twitter at @sfgiantsbeat. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.